Catering
ORDERING & GENERAL INFO
Whether you are coming together for a kids party, the Super Bowl, the Academy Awards or any type of event, Tomato Pie is here to help. We have the most authentic NY-Style pizza around, and we also serve larger portions of our delicious pastas, subs, and salads.
Choose between a small tray serving 10 people or a large tray serving 20 people. Pizzas can be cut into different slice configurations to accommodate your specific needs. We can customize most items to be sensitive to gluten or dairy allergies as well as make them kid-friendly.
Our drop-off catering is delivered in recyclable pans and cardboard boxes and can be arranged in a simple buffet-style upon delivery. We offer disposable plates, napkins, and utensils upon request.
All orders should be placed at least 24 hours before the event. Please allow a ten minute grace period for requested timed orders.
Our delivery fee is $5.99 for orders within our normal three-mile range. Additional charges apply for longer distances.
Credit card authorization required at time of ordering. A 10% gratuity is added to all deliveries over $150.
Please check our online menu for complete ingredients. Some items are not available at all locations.
APPETIZERS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
Garlic Knots
Served with marinara on the side
$19.00
$37.00
-
Hot Wings
Served with ranch on the side
$60.00
$120.00
-
Meatballs
$68.00
$136.00
-
Broccolini Limone
$63.00
$125.00
FRESH GREEN SALADS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
Antipasto
With balsamic vinaigrette
$43.00
$85.00
-
Caesar
With creamy caesar dressing
$33.00
$66.00
-
Mediterranean
With lemon vinaigrette
$45.00
$89.00
-
Add Grilled Chicken
$10.00
$20.00
SUBS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
$60.00
$120.00
-
Italian
-
Meatball
-
Chicken
STROMBOLI
24 slices | Similar to a calzone but longer and perfect for parties. Served with sides of ranch and marinara sauce.-
$34.00
-
Custom
Choose any four ingredients from the pie toppings list. Comes with mozzarella cheese
-
The Butcher
Pepperoni, american bacon, canadian bacon, mild sausage & mozzarella cheese
-
Vegetarian
Spinach, broccoli, onion, bell pepper, tomato, ricotta & mozzarella cheese
PASTAS
Small Serves 10 | Large Serves 20-
Pasta Marinara
Spaghetti, penne or rigatoni
$46.00
$91.00
-
Rigatoni with Meat Sauce
$58.00
$112.00
-
Penne with Pesto Cream
$72.00
$136.00
-
Alfredo
Penne or Pappardelle pasta
$74.00
$144.00
-
Chicken Riggies
$70.00
$130.00
-
Baked Ziti
$66.00
$124.00
-
Add Chicken
$10.00
$20.00
-
Change Pasta to Gluten Free Penne
$3.50
$7.00
Hand Tossed NY-Style
-
Traditional Cheese
Medium $21.00
Large $24.00
Gluten Free $23.00
-
Grandma
Medium $24.00
Large $27.00
Gluten-Free $26.00
-
Mr. White
Medium $25.00
Large $28.00
Gluten-Free $27.00
-
Blanco Veggie
Medium $31.00
Large $34.00
Gluten-Free $33.00
-
Miss Green
Medium $29.00
Large` $32.00
Gluten-Free $31.00
-
Florentine
Medium $25.00
Large $28.00
Gluten-Free $27.00
-
Really Really Funghi
Medium $29.00
Large $33.00
Gluten Free $31.00
-
Syracuse
Medium $27.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
The Notorious (SMG)
Medium $28.00
Large $31.00
Gluten-Free $30.00
-
Primo
Medium $30.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $32.00
-
BBQ Chicken
Medium $27.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
Deluxe
Medium $31.00
Large $35.00
Gluten-Free $34.00
-
Joe P
Medium $27.00
Large $30.00
Gluten-Free $29.00
-
Butcher
Medium $30.00
Large $33.00
Gluten-Free $32.00
Deep Dish Sicilian-Style
-
Sicilian Cheese
$30.00
-
Tomato Pie
$25.00
-
Great Grandma
$33.00
-
Utica
$36.00
Pizza Toppings
-
Cheese, All Pasteurized
Cheddar, vegan, feta, mozzarella, shaved parmesan, ricotta, romano
-
Vegetables
Artichoke, basil, banana pepper, black olive, broccoli, cilantro, garlic, green bell pepper, heirloom tomatoes, hot italian pepper, jalapeño, mushroom, pineapple, red bell pepper, roasted garlic, spinach, white onion, zucchini
-
Meats, Free of Hormones, Antibiotics & Msg
Anchovy, american bacon, canadian bacon, chicken, meatball, pepperoni, salami, mild sausage, spicy sausage